[1.12.1 - 1.12.2] An already working method suddenly stop working out of nowhere

[Gess1t 0]

forge recommended (1.12.1 - 14.22.1.2478)

 

so one of my 2 methods that check the inventory and send the message suddenly stopped working completely without editing it, copy pasting code from a known working method doesn't fix it, redoing the method does not fix it,  create the method under another name doesn't work, logs show nothing, it's just forge shenanigans at this point for me.

 

the method : 

 

@SubscribeEvent
	public static void PckUpItm(EntityItemPickupEvent event) {
		System.out.println("output1");
     	int g = 0;
		for(int e=0; e < 37; e++) {
			if(!Minecraft.getMinecraft().player.inventory.getStackInSlot(e).isEmpty() && Minecraft.getMinecraft()
					.player.inventory.getStackInSlot(e).getCount() == Minecraft.getMinecraft().player.inventory.getStackInSlot(e).getMaxStackSize()) {
				g++;
              	System.out.println("output2");
				if(g > 35) {
					Minecraft.getMinecraft().player.sendMessage(new TextComponentString("Your inventory is full"));
					System.out.println("output3");
                  	return;
					}
					
				}
				
			}				

		}

so i've added 3 output to console

the "output1" appear,

the "output2" appear 35 times? it should appear 36 times so wtf.

the "output3" does not appear at all obviously.

 

EDIT: last time i tried it, i started the game, and it was working, so i just closed the game, and i closed eclipse.

and when i came back to test it today, it wasn't working anymore

EDIT2: Added System.out.println(g) instead, it doesn't go higher than 35, even when editing the value to e < 38

Even More EDIT cause why not: it worked for one try, and now, value don't go higher than 35 when the other method goes to 36 flawlessly

Edited September 10 by Gess1t

[diesieben07 6692]

• Why on earth are you using 1.12.1? Update to 1.12.2.
• You are reaching across logical sides.

[Gess1t 0]

6 minutes ago, diesieben07 said:

• Why on earth are you using 1.12.1? Update to 1.12.2.
• You are reaching across logical sides.

i'm using 1.12.1 cause it's also compatible with 1.12.2

So i'm reaching across logicals sides now? why not before? like when the code was working flawlessly? even on servers!

Edited September 10 by Gess1t

[diesieben07 6692]

4 minutes ago, Gess1t said:

So i'm reaching across logicals sides now? why not before?

If you were doing the same thing before then you were already reaching across logical sides.

 

4 minutes ago, Gess1t said:

like when the code was working flawlessly? even on servers!

It wasn't. You just got lucky. And no, this code will never run on a server. The class Minecraft is not present on a server and your code will immediately crash with a NoClassDefFoundError.

[diesieben07 6692]

6 minutes ago, Gess1t said:

i'm using 1.12.1 cause it's also compatible with 1.12.2

So...? That does not justify using 1.12.1. 1.12.2 is a bug-fix update for 1.12.1. The only "advantage" you have from using 1.12.1 is more bugs. Use 1.12.2.

[Gess1t 0]

2 minutes ago, diesieben07 said:

If you were doing the same thing before then you were already reaching across logical sides.

 

It wasn't. You just got lucky. And no, this code will never run on a server. The class Minecraft is not present on a server and your code will immediately crash with a NoClassDefFoundError.

so i need to learn how to use packets now just because it refuse to work?

even hypixel accepted it

[diesieben07 6692]

Okay so.

Please clarify what you mean by "on a server".

Is this a client-only mod?

[Gess1t 0]

6 minutes ago, diesieben07 said:

Okay so.

Please clarify what you mean by "on a server".

Is this a client-only mod?

mostly, but i learned you can't make all things client side.

tried it while farming sugar canes on skyblock servers, worked flawlessly.

EDIT: i also had potentially found a way to add minecraft: IDs as exception for the check (for the nether star and the head cause backpacks and the menu aren't stackable items), but deleted it in the process of trying to fix it, will have to re-write all that later.

Edited September 10 by Gess1t

[diesieben07 6692]

Okay, if this is intended to be client-only then you still need to first check if you are actually on the logical client using World#isRemote. You can get the World from the EntityPlayer in the event.

 

Is your inventory actually full in these tests? Have you used the debugger?

[Gess1t 0]

14 minutes ago, diesieben07 said:

Okay, if this is intended to be client-only then you still need to first check if you are actually on the logical client using World#isRemote. You can get the World from the EntityPlayer in the event.

 

Is your inventory actually full in these tests? Have you used the debugger?

EDIT cause i'm retarded : if(Minecraft.getMinecraft().world.isRemote)

 

yup, in solo, worked with 64 in each of 36 inv slots, and same in multiplayer ans hypixel when i had the exception, didn't used any debugger.

Edited September 10 by Gess1t

[diesieben07 6692]

6 minutes ago, Gess1t said:

EDIT cause i'm retarded : if(Minecraft.getMinecraft().world.isRemote)

No! This is completely and utterly pointless.

 

Again: Have you used the debugger?

[Gess1t 0]

15 minutes ago, diesieben07 said:

No! This is completely and utterly pointless.

 

Again: Have you used the debugger?

then it is if(Minecraft.getMinecraft().player.world.isRemote)

EDIT: well nope, no need to tell me

 

and again, as i said in my previous message, no i didn't, cause i didn't needed one yet.

i guess now you ask that, that i need one?

Edited September 10 by Gess1t

[diesieben07 6692]

1 minute ago, Gess1t said:

then it is if(Minecraft.getMinecraft().player.world.isRemote)

Still makes no sense. Minecraft#world (Or Minecraft#player.world) is always the (logical) client world. isRemote will always be true. But at this point you do not know if you are even running on the logical client. You might be in single player with the event being fired on the logical server. And, boom, there is you reaching across logical sides (accessing logical client stuff from logical server).

 

Again:

25 minutes ago, diesieben07 said:

You can get the World from the EntityPlayer in the event. 

 

3 minutes ago, Gess1t said:

and again, as i said in my previous message, no i didn't, cause i didn't needed one yet

It's about time then.

[Animefan8888 677]

3 minutes ago, Gess1t said:

then it is if(Minecraft.getMinecraft().player.world.isRemote)

No.

 

25 minutes ago, diesieben07 said:

You can get the World from the EntityPlayer in the event.

 

[Gess1t 0]

29 minutes ago, diesieben07 said:

Still makes no sense. Minecraft#world (Or Minecraft#player.world) is always the (logical) client world. isRemote will always be true. But at this point you do not know if you are even running on the logical client. You might be in single player with the event being fired on the logical server. And, boom, there is you reaching across logical sides (accessing logical client stuff from logical server).

 

Again:

 

It's about time then.

my last try for today : event.getEntityPlayer().world.isRemote

there is world, but i can't find World

Edited September 10 by Gess1t

[Animefan8888 677]

16 minutes ago, Gess1t said:

my last try for today : event.getEntityPlayer().world.isRemote

This is correct.

 

16 minutes ago, Gess1t said:

World

This refers to the objects type name. While world refers to the field name.

[Gess1t 0]

tried to use the eclipse's debugger; bug it crash the game so... nope

added the line of code as an if statement like you told me, but as far as i know, this line of code alone won't help right?

[Animefan8888 677]

1 hour ago, Gess1t said:

bug it crash the game so... nope

The debugger itself won't crash the game. So some code is crashing the game or one of the threads is suspended. And you will need to un-suspend it.

[Gess1t 0]

32 minutes ago, Animefan8888 said:

The debugger itself won't crash the game. So some code is crashing the game or one of the threads is suspended. And you will need to un-suspend it.

should had edited it, it freeze and crash the game on the ms the game windows show up,

 

Edited September 13 by Gess1t

[Animefan8888 677]

2 hours ago, Gess1t said:

should had edited it, it freeze and crash the game on the ms the game windows show up,

I have a theory but since I dont have the crash log I'm not sure. But I think the problem is that the ClientTickEvent is called before the player is created. Thus you need to check if it is not null before you do the is remote check.

[Gess1t 0]

10 hours ago, Animefan8888 said:

I have a theory but since I dont have the crash log I'm not sure. But I think the problem is that the ClientTickEvent is called before the player is created. Thus you need to check if it is not null before you do the is remote check.

anyway, it started working again, i guess things want to work whenever they want, like my method for example, it worked for like 30 min and stopped working again after relaunching.

Still don't know how to fix it nothing special at all in the logs, when compared with other logs.

 

another edit cause why not: i wonder if the issue is forge or minecraft itself at this point, all this make no sense to me and probably you, am i right?

Edited September 14 by Gess1t

[4sterism 0]

Thats bc the code is not robust. It doesnt work in all possible situations.

[Gess1t 0]

so, is there any way to fix this issue? just adding event.getEntityPlayer().world.isRemote didn't helped in any way as far as i know and tested, on server and single player, i'm repeating myself i know.

 i've seen that the using Minecraft.getMinecraft() is client-side code or something like that. what should i use then?

Edited September 15 by Gess1t

[Gess1t 0]

i was wandering i could build the mod with one method, and then another mod with the other one, will i still reach across logical sides?

or it's just something else, like i need to send packets?

Edited September 16 by Gess1t

[diesieben07 6692]

Please show your current code and I will tell you if it is correct or not.