New Forge Art Contest

[LexManos 1560]

Hey folks!!!!

Great news. The contest was a hit and we've turned out some amazing new designs and logos. From everyone on the Forge team I want to say thanks for participating and giving us some awesome things to work with.

 

With that said though you all aren't reading this to see me say thanks so lets get down to the important stuff, like you know, who the hell won.

 

 

So without further distraction I present you our winner:

 

 

By: PitchBright

 

Now with every new thing something old must pass. So with that I'm also happy to announce that here is the next while we will also be updating the forums, website, and a few other things, to match our new branding.

 

Thanks again to everyone who submitted entries to the contest.

 

Cheers

 

TheTrotter

 

 

 

 

 

Introduction

Forge is in need of a new logo and due to the lack of a graphics designer in the core team, it was decided that the community should get the opportunity to design the new front for Forge.

 

The competition will run from today 09/08/16 to just before Minecon 09/20/16.

The extra 3 days is so I can order business card for the con

 

Results will be put up for a community vote with the final winner then being decided by me, LexManos. The winner will receive a $100 prize for their creation {Paid via paypal}, but will also transfer all rights to it over to me, ensuring no legal issues will arise in the future. Of course the artist will still be attributed as the original creator.

 

Requirements

Submissions must meet the following requirements:

[*]All assets must be free to use commercially. If third party assets are used in a creation, please refer to your source, enabling us to double check licenses.

[*]The logo should consist of both an icon and a wordmark, which have to be usable separated from one another. The text for the wordmark simply has to be "Forge" (without "Minecraft"). Requirement (1) also applies to the used typeface.

[*]If the logo uses colors, care should be taken that it also looks good in greyscale. If it does not (due to low contrast, for example), an alternative greyscale version has to be provided.

[*]Submissions should be in a vector format (preferably SVG). If you do not have access to vector art software, make sure that your rasterized creation is easily convertible to a vector format, i.e. try to limit it to simple, solid color shapes. If you use a raster format, including the name of the used typeface for the wordmark in your submission is essential!

[*]In addition to the logo itself, designs for business cards and an animation for the in-game loading screen are required. The animation should be using a vector format, too, if possible (e.g. using Synfig Studio), otherwise submit it as GIF with a transparent/white background or submit individual frames in a high-quality format. If you cannot animate the logo yourself, include a reasonably detailed description of what you would have wanted to achieve, maybe it can be added later on.

 

Use Cases

The winner's logo will be used in the following contexts and should be designed accordingly:

• Icon & Wordmark
  
  • Forum/website header
    
  • In-Game mod information page
    

   

  [*]Icon

  • Website favicon
    

   

  [*]Use cases for the animation and business cards are self-explanatory.

 

Additional Information

As stated above, the winner will transfer all rights to his creation to me, LexManos, in return for $100 prize money. Although you will still be credited appropriately, this is necessary to prevent legal issues with the usage of this logo. Additionally, you should be ready to take further (paid) design requests surrounding the Forge brand, e.g. webdesign for a new forum. If you are not versed in a given task, you should still be able to give council on how to keep new things in line with your design.

 

Business cards should have spots for Name, Email, and Website.

At the end of the day we want two made:

1) LexManos, Lex@ForgeDevelop.com, ForgeDevelop.com

2) Trotter, Trotter@ForgeDevelop.com, ForgeDevelop.com

 

 

Sending in your submission

To send in your submission, simply post a download link to all your files in a ZIP in response to this topic. The ZIP should contain a readme.txt file (no other format) which describes your general idea, lists your sources and optionally contains a description of the animation. Name all files appropriately to make them easily distinguishable from each other. You do not have to provide icon and wordmark as separate files unless they overlap each other in some way in the combined form.

 

 

[iLexiconn 2]

Here's my entry: https://ilexiconn.net/forge_logo_by_ilexiconn.zip

 

EDIT: Just changed the font to one that's free for commercial use

[jajo_11 0]

I don't really have time for a full submission, but made a concept anyway. If anyone wants to use it as a base, feel free to do so. The font I used can be found here https://fonts.google.com/specimen/Cutive+Mono

 

The idea is that a block is "casted" (animation could be the casting of blocks on a conveyor belt).

 

SVG:

https://1drv.ms/u/s!AhKRG_CI_vXjgrcj_kI4u8jR-Li1Tw

[Bottersnike 0]

Here's my submission: http://www.mediafire.com/download/z32tdth9wzmf18u/ForgeLogo_.zip

I've added slight depth to the logos. I've also fixed the white space on the B/W version. Business cards are now all there along with a blank one for your own use. The second animation and Synfig file are in there too.

 

Here's my submission: http://www.mediafire.com/download/n8pwm5xukfb31ff/ForgeLogo.zip

The business cards are at http://www.mediafire.com/download/91tw1ojo967j5lu/Buisness_Card.zip Don't use the ones in the other zip. I made new cards, but didn't want to re-upload the whole thing. There is also another idea for the animation at http://www.mediafire.com/download/mo314d07o630kox/Animation2.avi which Lex described in his post further down. (EDIT: Business cards have been updated with LexMannos' information and Trotter's. Use the same link for the business cards above.)

 

 

And because I made some others that were deemed not so good, I figured I'd just link them as inspiration for others:

http://www.mediafire.com/download/ki14nvjk9adg66v/Fail1.zip (View SVGs in Inkscape or IE/Edge for them to work)

http://www.mediafire.com/download/mha560p61dsuciz/Fail2.zip

 

I may yet make another if my current one is deemed s**t

 

P.S. if any of the links are broken just let me know and I'll fix them.

P.P.S. If any of the SVGs fail to load, it's probably because I forgot to export to a plain SVG from Inkscape. If you let me know, I can swap out the faulty SVG.

[silenz 0]

I'm fan of the Forge project and I would love to be part of it.

Here is my submission to the contest: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B99Vh0qXSkP-a19OTG5mWG8zM0E/view?usp=sharing

 

Edit:  Fixed business card to match updated requirements, link remains the same.

[effective 0]

Hello guys!

 

Here is my offer for the logo-design: www.il-online.at/upload_stuff/forge_logo.zip

 

However, I am always open to new suggestions!

 

 

Greetings,

effective

 

---

 

Edit:

 

- I added more information about the anvil and the hammer in the readme.txt (I had forgotten this - sorry!)

- The business cards have now a backside and I changed the text. (There is also a print and a preview version now the zip.)

- I added another PDF with some color information in it.

- I added 2 .svg files - RGB and CMYK - ready to use.

 

 

BTW: I can't send you a private message LexManos... "Has blocked your private message" appears^^

 

 

[PitchBright 0]

My 12 year old niece made this for you Lex. I think it's pretty good. She loves Forge, and is heavily into modding. It would break her little heart if you didn't like it.

 

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ga8s8hi89w44yo7/Forge_Brand.zip?dl=1

[LexManos 1560]

Whelp as we're getting close to the end I figured i'd step in and give my thoughts on what we currently have:

 

iLexiconn: I like its simplicity, a bit too on the nose with Minecraft. I'd like to stay away from cubes in general.

 

jajo_11: Interesting concept, again I like the simplicity. However the cube is a bit Minecrafty. And the single pixel border is rather hard to see at the sizes we'd most likely use this. Also, what font is that? Is it a permissive license?

 

Bottersnike: I think that the SVGs may be a little messed up as it doesn't render the full 'E' for me. However, I do like the hammers. Again fairly simple/clean and moving away from the dead-on Minecraft vibe. As for the animation I think it's nice, but it may be better if it was just one of the hammers going horizontal to vertical, as if striking. Only question I have is did you get the images for the hammers somewhere or are they 100% home grown?

 

silenz: Interesting concept, however my main concern is that its just the word Forge. And the 'logo' looks like an 'A' with a 'T' inside it and is a bit to confusing as nothing in Forge has a 'A' or a 'T'.

 

effective: I like it, it's simple, clean, the license for the font is permissive. My only concern so far is the icon itself. It seems to be a derivative of this, which isn't bad as it's a free/open icon as long as attribution is provided. Is the hammer taken from anywhere and can we verify its license? As for the card, get rid of the 'God' part, makes me sound arrogant, its on the forums as a joke. I usually just put "Lead Developer"

 

PitchBright: And finally to you, yours is definitely the most well presented So let's start off, the logo again as with the others I like the simplicity. Small anvil with the name simple, clean, can be put anywhere and just works. The anvil is clean enough that it can be used as a standalone icon and still be visible even at smaller sizes. However the artwork license is both a bit confusing and rather expensive. Not to mention that as we talked about before, it has too much of that 'Football' feel to it. Found an alternative here that has a much more permissive license and doesn't have the football feel. As for the business card, i would say use the 'corporate' as the back. And the logo on the front. Makes it cleaner/less busy. The fonts are however a question as I'm having difficulty understanding their license. If I understand it correctly we can buy the desktop license and we can then use it to create the images. Which are then freely distribuitable with no limitations?

 

Anways, this is my first pass at this all. I will say I'm heavily leaning towards effective and PitchBright right now as they are doing a good job moving away from the "THIS IS OBVIOUSLY MINECRAFT".

[Bottersnike 0]

I can confirm that the hammers are 100% home grown although vaguely based off http://gwellwood.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/hammer.jpg (I'm sure you'll see what I mean by vauge ) I'll give the animation idea a try and update the business card(s) with the information you edited in.

[Mchetvorkata 0]

My 12 year old niece made this for you Lex. I think it's pretty good. She loves Forge, and is heavily into modding. It would break her little heart if you didn't like it.

 

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ga8s8hi89w44yo7/Forge_Brand.zip?dl=1

I really don't want to look like a complete c*nt but like these are in my opinion extremely close to simmilar blacksmith labels and vectors.. I don't know i think if it is more unique and diffirent than the Forge's current logo : http://prntscr.com/cjxfo5 but at the same time i guess that is kind of the brand's thing but.. i don't know i like unique and new stuff. An idea just poped off in my head but it is too late i guess

[gurujive 34]

My 12 year old niece made this for you Lex. I think it's pretty good. She loves Forge, and is heavily into modding. It would break her little heart if you didn't like it.

 

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ga8s8hi89w44yo7/Forge_Brand.zip?dl=1

 

Did a 12 year old seriously do that? Like all of that from scratch?

If so impressive.

The man with the anvil is so-so, but the anvil icon is like a army knife anvil combo. Looks cool.

[Bottersnike 0]

My 12 year old niece made this for you Lex.

Not to be a dick, I think your submission is really cool but come on. Your 12 year old niece? http://lmgtfy.com/?q=blacksmith+vector

[LexManos 1560]

Alright guys. The contest is over. Thank you all for your submissions.

Once I get a moment I will have a post up announcing the winner.